Task 2 · · 18 samples

It is important for children to learn the difference between right and wrong at an early age. Punishment is necessary to help them learn this distinction. To what extent do you agree or disagree with the view? What sort of punishment do parenta and teachers be allowed to use to teach good behaviour to children .

Practise this task →

Plan your answer

Try your own response before reading the samples.

Ideas to explore

  • An explanation helps a child understand why an action matters.
  • A consequence can reinforce that explanation when it relates to the action.
  • There are important boundaries.

Suggested structure

  1. Give a direct introduction and state the required position.
  2. Explain the first side or reason with a relevant example.
  3. Address the second side and the conditions that limit the claim.
  4. Return to the precise question in the conclusion.
Useful vocabulary & examples
a qualified judgement
a conclusion with stated limits

Children need to learn right and wrong, but punishment is not always necessary to teach that distinction. I support clear explanations and proportionate non-physical consequences, with no place for violence or humiliation.

practical consequences
effects on ordinary decisions or activities

Children need to learn right and wrong, but punishment is not always necessary to teach that distinction. I support clear explanations and proportionate non-physical consequences, with no place for violence or humiliation.

a realistic alternative
another option that can work in the circumstances

Children need to learn right and wrong, but punishment is not always necessary to teach that distinction. I support clear explanations and proportionate non-physical consequences, with no place for violence or humiliation.

Sample answers

AI-completed learning example

360 words · Illustrative target band

Learning the distinction between good and bad is an essential part of a young child’s education. some people feel that in order to teach this difference it is necessary to punish them. I partially agree with this idea, and I believe it really depends on the type of punishment; no violence should be allowed. Children need a response they can understand. An explanation helps a child understand why an action matters. I…

Read full answer & analysis →

AI-completed learning example

367 words · Illustrative target band

Whilst some people say that punishment is wrong for children development, I do believe that punishment is essential for children to justify their actions in the early years of their lives. On one hand, many children who got punishment when did wrong things shows positive changes in their behaviors. It could be seen that some children benefit from a clear connection between their conduct and a manageable consequence. …

Read full answer & analysis →

AI-completed learning example

361 words · Illustrative target band

Some would argue that it is essential that children are taught morals from an early age and punishment is the best way to do it. This essay totally agrees with that statement because they will be punished at school and by the authorities when they get older if they break the rules, however, parents should use consequences to teach rather than threaten. An explanation helps a child understand why an action matters. I…

Read full answer & analysis →